Case Studies

The stated problem was not the real problem.

An expatriate country manager. A stakeholder map. Leadership presence coaching. A regional president working seventy-hour weeks. Each time, the brief we were given was reasonable, and each time the real problem sat underneath it. Finding it is what changed the outcome.

Steve and Bryan McKinney
CASE 01
Executive SearchConsumer goodsKorea

The country manager seat that had defeated two people

2020Year placed. Still in the seat.
<24 moTenure of each of the two previous incumbents.
3 weeksSpent rewriting the mandate before searching.

The situation

A multinational consumer brand's Korea business was drifting. The country manager seat had turned over twice in three years. Headquarters was losing patience. And the local team had learned the most corrosive lesson a team can learn, which is that the way to handle a new leader is to wait them out.

The brief we were given

Find another polished expatriate from the region. That was the brief, and it was the same brief that had produced the two previous incumbents.

What we did instead

We declined to search against it.

We told the global CHRO directly that a hire to that specification would bring the company back to us within eighteen months. The problem was not that the previous two leaders were weak. The problem was that the job had been written for a business that no longer existed, and no candidate, however impressive, was going to survive a role designed to fail.

We then spent three weeks rewriting the mandate. Not the title or the compensation band, but the substance of the role.

  • Who the new leader actually had to move, inside Korea and inside headquarters
  • Which headquarters relationships had to be broken and rebuilt rather than inherited
  • What the first ninety days in Seoul had to look like if the local team was going to stop waiting

Who we placed

A Korean national with operating scars rather than a career manager. Someone who had been through difficulty in the market, rather than someone whose record was unblemished because it had never been tested.

What we did after the placement

We stayed through the transition. For the executive's entire first year, a standing Friday call worked whatever problem was in front of them that week. Not a check-in and not an onboarding review, but a working session on the live problem.

The outcome

Placed in 2020. Still in the seat. The two previous incumbents did not reach twenty-four months.

Over the same period, the Korea business moved from a chronic underperformer inside the region to an operation that headquarters began citing as a template. Tenure is tracked from the placement date. The turnaround is reflected in the client's own regional business reviews.

CASE 02
Executive CoachingRegional leadershipNorth Asia

The leader who did not know if he was allowed to lose

6 monthsLength of the coaching engagement.
2.5 yearsTime to expanded regional scope.
3Transition dimensions the work turned on.

The situation

A Korean country general manager, newly named to a regional role covering North Asia. Twenty years of career built on never missing a number in a market he understood completely.

What had already been tried

Forty minutes in a Seoul office on the standard checklist. Stakeholder maps, headquarters cadence, the mechanics of leading across three time zones. It landed nowhere. Everything on that list was correct and none of it was the problem.

What surfaced when the question changed

Steve stopped working the checklist and asked what he was actually afraid of. After a long pause, the executive answered.

“I know how to win in Korea. I don't know if I'm allowed to lose in Japan.”

The diagnosis

The problem was not capability. It was permission.

The regional seat would force calls he would sometimes get wrong, in public, in front of country teams who had been in those markets longer than he had. Nothing in twenty years of never missing a number had prepared him for that, because nothing in twenty years had required it.

What the work became

Six months on three things.

  • Leading from questions in the two markets he did not yet own
  • Letting his Japan and Greater China country heads teach him without surrendering authority
  • Telling headquarters early when something went sideways

The outcome

Two and a half years later, he runs a larger piece of the business than the one he was promoted into.

CASE 03
Proactive Agility™Scenario rehearsalKorea

The channel shift headquarters did not believe was real

2013First run, before the method was named.
2022Most recent run, described here.
2 quartersUntil the local business was setting regional policy.

The situation

We first ran this drill in 2013, a decade before Proactive Agility had a name. We ran it again in 2022, with a country manager in Seoul who was sharp, strong on paper, and freezing under a channel shift that nobody at headquarters believed was happening.

What the engagement was supposed to be

Work on leadership presence. That was the brief, and on the evidence of the executive's profile it was a reasonable brief.

What we did instead

Dropped it, and drilled scenarios.

  • What to do if a key account walked
  • What to do if a competitor priced below cost
  • What to do if Seoul had to lead headquarters rather than the other way around

Not strategy sessions. Repeated rehearsal of decisions the executive had never had to make, until making them stopped requiring permission.

The outcome

The executive stopped waiting for permission. Within two quarters, the Korea business was making calls that the region later adopted as policy.

CASE 04
Executive CoachingRegional leadershipAsia

The regional president who was carrying the region, and slowing it down

3 monthsCoaching engagement, meeting almost every week.
2 of 2At-risk country managers retained.
4Transition dimensions the work turned on.

The situation

An American executive at a US multinational, newly appointed regional president for Asia. His record in the United States was strong. He had energy, technical credibility and a reputation for making things happen.

Within his first year, he was working seventy-hour weeks and was involved in nearly every consequential decision across the region. When a country manager brought him a plan, he rewrote it. When a local approach differed from the way headquarters did it, he pushed back until it matched. Country managers had stopped bringing ideas forward, and two of the strongest were close to leaving.

What he believed

That he was carrying the region, and that if he stepped back, things would get worse.

The diagnosis

The problem was not capability. It was the transition. The habits that had made him successful, deep expertise, fast decisions and personal follow-through, had become the constraint in the bigger role. He was leading a region the way he had led a function.

What the work became

Three months, meeting almost every week, on four things.

  • Managing his own energy and attention, so his time went to the decisions only he could make
  • Leading through others, handing plans and decisions back to the country managers who owned them
  • Stakeholder influence, with headquarters and with his own regional team
  • Global Mindset, letting local approaches stand where they fit the market better

The outcome

He kept both country managers who had been close to leaving, and the region went on to exceed its sales targets.

About McKinney Consulting

Founded in Seoul in 2001. Clients return.

McKinney Consulting is an executive search and leadership coaching firm, and Korea partner for Kestria. We have completed assignments for organizations including Ford, General Motors, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Airbus, General Electric, Siemens, Shell, Pfizer, Johnson and Johnson, Roche, PepsiCo, Coca-Cola, Mars, Cisco, Oracle, Qualcomm, Visa, Citigroup and Deloitte, as well as diplomatic missions in Korea.

7Separate mandates for one global automotive systems supplier, across sales, engineering, operations and finance.
4Senior roles for a leading international insurer: CFO, HR director, regional IT director and legal counsel.

All case studies are reported without identifying the client. Outcomes are tracked from placement or engagement dates and, where relevant, corroborated by the client's own business reviews.

Start the Conversation

Is the brief in front of you the real problem?

Tell us what you're facing. We'll tell you plainly what we see.

Executive Search

A leadership seat that has to hold

Retained search for country manager, president and C-suite roles in Korea and across Asia-Pacific.

Executive Search
Executive Coaching

A leader stepping into a bigger role

The Bigger-Role Transition Program, six months of confidential work for leaders taking on greater responsibility.

Executive Coaching
Keynotes & Workshops

A team that has to act before change

Proactive Agility keynotes and workshops for leadership offsites, regional meetings and conferences.

Proactive Agility
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram